Cultural Klutziness vs. Diversity
Posted by Sherry MartsOct 19
Let me first post a disclaimer: the followng is my individual opinion and is not an official statement from the GSA, its Board, or anyone else on its staff.
This morning I listened to a generally entertaining opening address presented by the president of a scientific society. Now, one of the risks you take when injecting humor into a presentation is the risk of unintentionally offending or insulting a portion of your audience. This address had two of those moments of cultural klutziness. Keep in mind that the speaker is a White, middle-aged man.
1. He used photographs of women in bikinis to get a laugh from his audience.
2. He stated that Christopher Columbus discovered “a place that no one knew existed. . .”
He concluded his address with a statement about the importance of diversity in the scientific workforce.
His statement about what Christopher Columbus accomplished is particularly hard to forgive. Are Native Americans still this invisible? Apparently it is possible to rise through the ranks of higher education in the US and still be completely unconscious of the history of European conquest in the Western hemisphere.
The photo of women in bikinis? I sure do hope I don’t have to recap 40 years of feminist sociopolitical scholarship to convince readers of this blog that this just doesn’t belong in a talk at a conference, even as a lame attempt at humor. Surely, he would never have used an image that reinforced negative stereotypes of Blacks, Jews, Asians, or any other minority group. Why are offensive, stereotyped images of women still acceptable?
I don’t know if there are any Native Americans attending this conference, and I can only hope I wasn’t the only person listening who cringed at his statement about Columbus.
There are plenty of young women scientist at the conference, and I guarantee that the message of that image here.If we really want to promote diversity in the scientific workforce, we all have to resist using